Future of ID

Instructional Design Capability Lab

Module 2Design Practice

Performance Consulting and Business Alignment

Learn how to connect course requests to business goals, performance gaps, and real workplace needs.

Module 2Estimated time: 20 minDesign Practice

Performance Consulting and Business Alignment

Learner question

What problem are we actually solving?

Learn how to connect course requests to business goals, performance gaps, and real workplace needs.

Takeaway: Better diagnosis leads to better learning solutions.

A course request is a signal to diagnose the performance system, not an automatic order to build training. Performance consulting means you investigate the business problem, define the performance gap, and identify the conditions influencing behavior. In this module, you'll ask targeted questions, align work to measurable outcomes, and decide when training is not the solution.
+What You'll Be Able to DoView outcomes

By the end of this module, you should be able to:

  • Distinguish a course request from an underlying performance problem.
  • Use stakeholder discovery questions to clarify business goals and constraints.
  • Identify performance gaps, root causes, and non-training factors that affect results.
  • Connect performance consulting work to HPI, needs analysis, Kirkpatrick, and ROI thinking.
Layer 1

Theory

This layer shows how to diagnose the real problem before you design a learning solution.

+Capability Definition

In practice, performance consulting means you define the business result, identify the required performance, and decide whether learning, process changes, tools, incentives, or environment will drive that result. Your role shifts from building content to improving the conditions that drive performance.

+Business Alignment

Start with the operational goal. Then connect your work directly to the result it must support. Don't start with a course request. Clarify what needs to change, who must perform differently, what success looks like, and how it will be measured.

+Stakeholder Discovery

Use discovery questions to understand the business context behind the request. Ask about the current state, desired state, audience, constraints, consequences, prior attempts, and available evidence. Then ask what decisions stakeholders are willing to make if training won't solve the problem.

+Needs Analysis

Use needs analysis to separate symptoms from root causes. A training request might point to a knowledge gap or to unclear expectations, broken workflows, weak manager support, poor tools, misaligned incentives, or missing feedback loops.

+Performance Gaps

A performance gap is the difference between current behavior and the behavior required to achieve the desired result. Define the gap in observable terms so you avoid vague goals and design for real workplace behavior.

+L&D Theory Bridge
  • HPI / performance improvement

    Use Human Performance Improvement to examine factors beyond training, including environment, process, information, tools, motivation, and feedback. This approach expands your solution options beyond instruction.

  • Kirkpatrick

    Use Kirkpatrick to connect learning decisions to behavior and results. Performance consulting makes evaluation stronger because you define the outcome before choosing the solution.

  • Needs analysis

    Use needs analysis to keep discovery focused. Check whether the gap comes from knowledge, skill, motivation, process, tools, expectations, or other workplace conditions.

  • ROI thinking

    Use ROI thinking to evaluate value, cost, evidence, and business impact. Not every project needs a financial calculation, but every project needs a clear definition of what improvement is worth pursuing.

+Evidence and Source Notes

The module combines established performance-improvement practice with Bradley's interpretation of how to interrupt solution-first requests.

  • Established principle — ISPI performance standards

    The International Society for Performance Improvement's Certified Performance Technologist Performance Standards support systematic analysis, cause analysis, solution design, implementation, and evaluation beyond training alone.

  • Established evaluation model — Kirkpatrick and Kirkpatrick (2006)

    Evaluating Training Programs: The Four Levels, 3rd edition, 2006, supports distinguishing reaction, learning, behavior, and results. The model informs evaluation; it did not select Bradley's capability pathway.

  • Bradley interpretation

    The request-to-diagnosis sequence and the decision to begin with an assumed training solution reflect Bradley's professional interpretation of how performance consulting can be practiced under real project constraints.

Layer 2

Experience

This layer gives learners practice reframing a stakeholder's course request into a performance consulting conversation. The goal is not to find the fastest solution; it is to identify the real performance problem before proposing learning.

Course Request Triage

Review a stakeholder request for a new training course and identify what is known, what is assumed, and what still needs to be discovered. The goal is to avoid jumping directly from request to deliverable.

Applied Decision-Making

Choose the discovery questions that would best clarify the business goal, target audience, current performance, desired behavior, operational constraints, and evidence of the gap. Then decide whether the likely solution is training, performance support, manager enablement, process improvement, or a blend.

Feedback and Insight

Compare the selected questions against performance consulting criteria. Strong responses focus on outcomes, behavior, root causes, and evidence rather than only content topics or preferred delivery formats.

Situational mental model

From Request to Diagnosis

  1. 01Stakeholder Request
  2. 02Performance Problem
  3. 03Evidence
  4. 04Root Cause
  5. 05Recommendation

Design practice

Choose a professional design decision, explain your reasoning, and use AI feedback as a structured critique. You can move in order or select the decision point most relevant to your work.

Scenario

You are asked to create a training program because sales performance has dropped over the last quarter. Your stakeholder believes the issue is that sales reps are not following the correct process and wants a course built immediately. However, you suspect the problem may not be caused by a lack of knowledge alone. What would you do in this situation, and how would you approach the request?

As you respond, name the stakeholder's stated request, the performance problem that may sit beneath it, the evidence or questions you still need, any non-training factors that could affect performance, and the next step you would defend.

0 / 1200 characters (20 minimum)

Layer 3

Reverse Build

Inspect the Build

You just experienced this as a learner. Now let's inspect it as an instructional designer.

Reverse Build reconstructs the learning experience, not the module topic or the code. It reveals the challenge you practiced, the thinking behind the design, how AI supported the work, and the trade-offs that shaped the experience.

The learning challenge
The decision you practiced
The AI-supported critique
Reflection and transfer

Reconstruct the Experience

Bradley's professional experience is that training requests can arrive as symptoms or assumed solutions before the performance problem is clear. This module was built to interrupt that observed pattern by moving learners from stakeholder request, to performance problem, to evidence, to root cause, to recommendation. The goal is not to claim that every request follows this pattern, but to help designers ask better questions and determine whether training is likely to improve performance.

The Problem

What This Module Is Solving

What this experience was built to solve before any design choices were made.

Bradley's professional observation is that some training requests begin with a symptom and an assumed solution. This module is designed to interrupt order-taking by helping designers move from request to diagnosis before they prescribe, while avoiding a claim that all organizations or requests behave this way.

Instructional Foundations

Proven Practice vs New Approach

5 moves

How modern practice connects back to established instructional design and learning science.

Design Decisions

Key Design Decisions

5 moves

Why the experience was scoped, sequenced, simplified, or emphasized this way.

We made a deliberate choice to start with a flawed request instead of a clean problem statement.

AI Collaboration

How AI Supported the Build

5 moves

Where AI accelerated exploration, variation, critique, or drafting without owning the decision.

AI helped expand the range of stakeholder scenarios and feedback, but it did not determine the right answer.

Design Trade-offs

Tradeoffs and Constraints

5 moves

Where the experience balances realism, clarity, complexity, guidance, autonomy, automation, and human review.

This design prioritizes diagnosis over speed, which creates tension.

Design Trade-offs

Where This Could Break

5 moves

Where the experience balances realism, clarity, complexity, guidance, autonomy, automation, and human review.

This approach depends on the designer's ability to navigate stakeholder conversations.

Learning Science & Transfer

What Another Designer Can Reuse

6 moves

How this reasoning can transfer into future instructional design practice.

The most reusable element is the request-to-diagnosis pattern: stakeholder request, performance problem, evidence, root cause, recommendation.

Learning Science & Transfer

Reflection Question

How this reasoning can transfer into future instructional design practice.

Think of a recent training request you received. What assumption was built into that request? What would you need to know to confirm whether the problem was performance, knowledge, or something else—and how would you ask for that information without slowing the work down so much that you lose stakeholder support?

Transfer to Your Practice

What might this way of thinking change in your own instructional design practice?

Reverse Build is not a correct-answer key. It is professional reasoning made visible so you can study it, question it, adapt it, and apply it. Professional judgment is learnable.

Reflection

Think of a recent or realistic course request. What assumption would you challenge, what evidence would you still need, and what diagnosis remains yours as the instructional designer before recommending a solution?

0 / 1200 characters (20 minimum)

Choose what you are curious about next.

Follow the next capability or return to the Capability Map. Learners may begin anywhere; there is no required sequence.

Explore Next Capability →Return to Capability Map